California dealers declare war on Scout Motors' direct sales model
Scout Motors is facing legal opposition from California’s dealer association, citing state laws prohibiting automakers from competing with their own franchisees.
Scout Motors hasn't delivered its first vehicle yet and it's already running into trouble.
The California New Car Dealers Association (CNCDA) has taken issue with Scout Motors and its parent company, Volkswagen Group (VW), over plans to sell Scout vehicles directly to consumers.
According to the CNCDA, this strategy violates a 2023 amendment to California’s State Vehicle Code, which prevents automakers and their affiliates from bypassing their franchise dealerships. Scout Motors, which Volkswagen revived to reimagine the classic Scout off-roaders, is at the center of the dispute due to its plans to cut out traditional dealerships entirely.
Related: 2025 Subaru Impreza: 6 reasons to love it, 3 reasons to think twice
Volkswagen’s defense of Scout
Scout Motors has argued that it operates independently from VW, a claim central to its defense. However, the CNCDA disputes this, citing VW’s financial and operational involvement, including funding Scout’s new production facility in South Carolina. These connections, the association contends, make Scout an affiliate of VW rather than an independent startup. Scout
Volkswagen has defended Scout’s status as an independent entity, claiming the brand operates more like Tesla, which also sells its vehicles directly. Tesla, however, was grandfathered into California law before the 2023 amendment took effect and has never relied on traditional dealerships. Scout, on the other hand, faces scrutiny because of its direct financial backing from VW, one of the world’s largest automakers.
The CNCDA’s concerns were detailed in a Dec. 20 letter addressed to Scout Motors’ general counsel Neil Sitron and Volkswagen Group of America’s general counsel Antony Klapper. The letter highlights that Scout had previously acknowledged the legal restrictions but has proceeded with its direct sales model regardless. The CNCDA warned that it is prepared to escalate the issue if Scout does not immediately cease its direct-to-consumer sales plans.
Related: Volkswagen's Golf is about to get a lot more expensive
A legal showdown looms
The legal dispute could significantly impact Scout Motors’ rollout of the Terra and Traveler models, both scheduled for release in 2027. While Scout’s direct sales approach is designed to mimic Tesla’s model, it is unclear whether courts will view the startup as sufficiently independent from VW. Scout
This battle comes at a pivotal time for the automotive industry, as traditional dealerships face increasing pressure from manufacturers seeking more control over the customer experience.
Related: Reviving these five models might save Mitsubishi
Final thoughts
Scout appears to be positioning itself as a Rivian and Tesla alternative, two companies that sell directly to the consumer. Without that model, it could lose out on some sales from buyers who prefer not to deal with a dealership.
For VW, the stakes go beyond Scout Motors; the outcome could set a precedent for how legacy automakers navigate the evolving retail landscape. Whether Scout’s nostalgic SUVs will resonate with buyers or be mired in legal challenges remains to be seen, but the decision will undoubtedly shape the future of car sales in California and beyond.
